Aluminum Alloy vs Galvanized Steel

Aluminum alloy and galvanized steel are two common metal materials widely used in industry and manufacturing. But what are the differences between them? This article will compare aluminum alloy and galvanized steel, detailing their distinctions, advantages, and disadvantages, providing you with a deeper understanding of both materials.

Aluminum Alloy

What is Aluminum Alloy?

What is Aluminum Alloy

Aluminum alloy is a material formed by adding other elements such as copper, magnesium, silicon, zinc, and manganese to pure aluminum. Alloying pure aluminum alters its mechanical properties and physical characteristics, enabling its use in various fields.

Types of Aluminum Alloys

1000 Series (Pure): This is essentially pure aluminum with an aluminum content of 99% or higher, containing only trace amounts of other elements. Pure aluminum is commonly used in chemical containers, electrical cables, and rivets.

2000 Series (Copper): These are aluminum-copper alloys. Copper is the primary alloying element, and the specific 2000 series alloys vary slightly in copper and other trace elements content. Aluminum-copper alloys have good strength and heat resistance and can be heat-treated. They are often used in aerospace and military applications.

3000 Series (Manganese): These are aluminum-manganese alloys. Manganese is the primary alloying element. These alloys have moderate strength, good corrosion resistance, and good formability but cannot be heat-treated. They are commonly used in cookware, automotive parts, and building materials.

4000 Series (Silicon): These are aluminum-silicon alloys. Silicon is the primary alloying element. These alloys have moderate strength, good corrosion resistance, and good machinability, making them commonly used in welding materials and architectural decoration.

5000 Series (Magnesium): These are aluminum-magnesium alloys. Magnesium is the primary alloying element, giving these alloys good strength and corrosion resistance, and making them ideal for marine applications.

6000 Series (Magnesium and Silicon): These are aluminum-magnesium-silicon alloys. Magnesium and silicon are the primary alloying elements. These alloys have good strength and corrosion resistance and are machinable, making them widely used for structural components in the automotive and construction industries.

7000 Series (Zinc): These are aluminum-zinc alloys. Zinc is the primary alloying element. These alloys offer extremely high strength and hardness, excellent fatigue resistance, and good corrosion resistance, and they can be heat-treated. They are commonly used in aerospace and high-performance sports equipment for high-strength applications.

What is Galvanized Steel?

What is Galvanized Steel

Galvanizing is a common metal surface treatment process that involves coating steel with a protective layer of zinc. This process enhances the corrosion resistance of the steel and extends its lifespan.

Types of Galvanized Steel

Hot-Dip Galvanized Steel: This type of galvanized steel is made by immersing the steel in a bath of molten zinc and then allowing it to cool. This process forms a thick zinc coating on the steel’s surface, providing excellent corrosion resistance. However, the surface tends to be rough, making it suitable for outdoor environments such as highway guardrails.

Electro-Galvanized Steel: This type of galvanized steel is created by immersing the steel in a zinc salt solution and applying an electric current, which deposits a thin zinc layer on the steel’s surface through electrolysis. While the zinc coating is thinner and less durable than that of hot-dip galvanizing, it results in a smoother surface. This makes electro-galvanized steel ideal for indoor environments and applications requiring a high-quality finish.

Differences Between Aluminum Alloy and Galvanized Steel

Weight 

Aluminum alloy has a lower density, typically around 2.7g/cm³, while galvanized steel has a higher density, generally around 7.85g/cm³. Therefore, products made from aluminum alloy are lighter than those made from galvanized steel, given the same specifications.

Strength 

The strength of aluminum alloy depends largely on the alloying elements added. Generally, aluminum alloys have good strength, and with proper treatment, they can achieve even higher strength levels.

The strength of galvanized steel depends on the steel’s composition and manufacturing process. Higher carbon content results in harder steel with less toughness. However, steel inherently has high strength, and the galvanizing process has minimal impact on its mechanical properties. Consequently, galvanized steel typically has very high strength.

Corrosion Resistance

Corrosion Resistance

Aluminum Alloy: Aluminum alloys have a dense oxide layer on their surface that effectively protects the metal from oxidation and corrosion. The corrosion resistance of aluminum alloys varies slightly depending on the alloying elements used, with aluminum-zinc alloys typically offering better resistance. Generally, aluminum alloys have good corrosion resistance, making them suitable for harsh environments such as marine or industrial applications.

Galvanized Steel: Galvanized steel has a protective zinc coating on its surface that prevents oxidation and corrosion. The thickness of the zinc layer affects the corrosion resistance of galvanized steel—the thicker the zinc coating, the better the corrosion resistance. However, an excessively thick zinc layer can impact the steel’s mechanical properties. Therefore, the appropriate zinc coating thickness should be chosen based on specific needs. Generally, galvanized steel offers good corrosion resistance, but it’s important to note that if the zinc coating is worn away, the corrosion resistance will be significantly reduced, and the underlying steel will become susceptible to rust.

Thermal Conductivity

Aluminum Alloy: The thermal conductivity of aluminum alloys typically ranges from 150 to 230 W/(m*K). While the thermal performance can vary slightly among different types of aluminum alloys, they generally offer excellent thermal conductivity. This makes aluminum alloys suitable for electrical and heat conduction applications.

Galvanized Steel: Galvanized steel has a lower thermal conductivity, usually between 45 and 60 W/(m*K). The thickness of the zinc coating can cause slight variations in thermal performance. However, galvanized steel’s thermal conductivity is significantly lower than that of aluminum alloys, making it more suitable for applications where high thermal conductivity is not required.

Formability

Aluminum Alloy: Aluminum alloys are soft and highly ductile, making them easy to shape through processes like extrusion, stretching, bending, stamping, and forging. This excellent formability makes aluminum alloys ideal for manufacturing complex-shaped parts.

Galvanized Steel: Galvanized steel also has good formability. However, the condition of the zinc coating can affect its corrosion resistance. During the forming process, care must be taken to protect the zinc coating from wear or damage to maintain the material’s corrosion resistance.

Cost

Cost

Aluminum Alloy: Aluminum alloys are lightweight and offer excellent corrosion resistance, heat resistance, thermal conductivity, and formability. However, their production costs are relatively high, leading to a higher price compared to other materials.

Galvanized Steel: The production costs of galvanized steel are relatively low, especially in large-scale manufacturing. As a result, galvanized steel is generally less expensive than aluminum alloys.

Conclusion

Aluminum alloy and galvanized steel are both commonly used metal materials, each with its own set of advantages. From the comprehensive comparison above, it’s clear that aluminum alloy is well-suited for applications requiring lightweight, high strength, and high corrosion resistance. On the other hand, galvanized steel is ideal for applications needing high strength, good corrosion resistance, and cost-effectiveness. The choice of which metal to use depends primarily on the specific application requirements. It’s essential to consider the material properties, advantages, disadvantages, and costs to select the most suitable material.

Scroll to Top